top of page
  • Curan & Ahlers

If Someone Brake Checks You, Who Is At Fault?

Fault in Brake Check Incidents: Understanding Legal Responsibilities on the Road

Driving on New York's busy roads requires more than just knowledge of traffic laws; it demands an understanding of how sudden actions, like brake checking, can lead to accidents. But when these incidents occur, determining fault isn't always straightforward.

This blog post delves into the nuances of fault in brake check situations, guiding drivers on how to navigate these tricky scenarios.

What Is Brake Checking?

Brake checking occurs when a driver deliberately slams on their brakes in front of another vehicle, often without any legitimate reason. This maneuver can be a response to tailgating or as an aggressive act of road rage. In the eyes of New York law, brake checking is not only dangerous but potentially illegal, depending on the circumstances and outcomes.

Understanding Fault in Brake Check Accidents

Traditionally, in rear-end collisions, the trailing driver is often presumed to be at fault for not maintaining a safe following distance. However, in incidents involving brake checking, this presumption can be challenged. Questions like "if someone brake checks you who is at fault" and "if you brake check someone who is at fault" highlight the complexity of these situations. Determining "who is at fault in a brake check accident" requires a careful examination of the events leading up to the collision.

The Legal Ramifications of Brake Checking

In New York, aggressive driving behaviors, including brake checking, can lead to significant legal consequences. If an accident results from such an action, determining "what happens if you brake check someone and they hit you" involves assessing negligence and reckless driving charges, potentially impacting both insurance claims and legal responsibilities.

Determining Fault: Brake Check Incidents

Fault determination in brake check cases isn't black and white. "If someone rear ends you who is at fault" typically points towards the rear driver, but "who is at fault if someone brake checks you" can shift blame to the lead driver if it's proven they acted recklessly. The critical question, "if someone brake checks me am I at fault," depends on the ability to prove the lead driver's intentional misconduct. Essentially, "are you at fault if someone brake checks you" can vary based on evidence, witness statements, and the specifics of the incident.

Protecting Yourself and Your Rights

If you're faced with a brake check situation, the best response is to maintain a safe distance and avoid confrontation. Should an accident occur, documenting the scene, gathering witness testimonies, and seeking legal counsel are vital steps. 

Currently, the state of New York has no specific laws related to the use of Dash Cameras. Installing a Dash Cam in your car will let you record any accident in the direction of the camera, which could be important evidence in a brake check accident. 

Understanding your rights and the legal framework surrounding "if someone brake checks you who is at fault" ensures you're prepared to defend your position.

Curan & Ahlers: New York Car Accident Lawyers

Brake checking is a hazardous maneuver that complicates the process of determining fault. Whether questioning "if someone brake checks you who is at fault" or dealing with the aftermath of an incident, the key lies in understanding the nuances of the law and the importance of safe driving practices. In situations where fault is disputed, professional legal representation can make a significant difference.

If you've been involved in a brake check incident and are unsure about "who is at fault if someone brake checks you," Curan & Ahlers is here to help. Our team of experienced personal injury lawyers can provide the guidance and representation you need to navigate the complexities of your case.

Contact us today for a consultation and take the first step towards protecting your rights on the road.

Areas We Serve:


bottom of page