top of page
  • Curan & Ahlers

Who is at Fault in a Right Turn Accident in New York?

Navigating the Maze of Liability: Who Bears Responsibility in a Right Turn Accident in New York?

As experienced personal injury lawyers in New York, we’ve worked on numerous cases involving accidents that were a result of right turns gone wrong. These incidents can cause significant injuries, property damage, and legal complications. Understanding who is at fault in a right-turn accident is crucial for protecting your rights and seeking compensation.

In this article, we will explore the intricacies of right-turn accidents in New York, shed light on liability factors, discuss legal considerations, and offer practical tips to prevent such accidents.

Right-of-Way Rules in New York

To comprehend who bears responsibility in a right-turn accident, we must first grasp the right-of-way rules in New York. Generally, when making a right turn, drivers must yield to pedestrians and oncoming traffic, ensuring a safe passage. However, specific rules apply within the state.

In New York, pedestrians always have the right of way unless traffic signals indicate otherwise. Drivers must exercise caution and yield to pedestrians when making a right turn at an intersection, even if there is no designated crosswalk. Additionally, vehicles approaching from the opposite direction must be given priority, and drivers should only proceed when the intersection is clear.

Common Causes of Right Turn Accidents

Several factors contribute to right-turn accidents. Driver negligence and inattention are primary causes. Distracted driving, such as using mobile devices or eating, significantly increases the risk of an accident. Failing to signal intentions, misjudging the speed of oncoming traffic, or improperly executing a turn can also lead to collisions.

Specific scenarios pose a higher risk for right-turn accidents. For instance, when a driver turns right while a pedestrian is crossing the street or when two vehicles attempt to make simultaneous right turns, confusion and miscommunication may arise, resulting in an accident.

Determining Fault in Right Turn Accidents

In New York, determining fault in a right-turn accident is a crucial step in seeking compensation. The state follows a "pure comparative negligence" system, which means that liability can be shared between parties based on their respective degree of fault.

To assign fault, various factors are considered, such as traffic laws, right-of-way rules, and the actions of all involved parties. It's important to note that even if you believe you may be partially at fault, you may still be eligible for compensation.

Let's consider a few scenarios to better understand the fault assignment process:

  • Scenario A: The turning driver fails to yield to a pedestrian and strikes them while making a right turn. In this case, the turning driver is likely to be held primarily liable for the accident.

  • Scenario B: The driver traveling straight disregards a red light and collides with a turning vehicle. Here, the driver traveling straight may share responsibility for running a red light, while the turning driver may bear partial fault for not yielding to oncoming traffic. If the driver turning right had a green turn arrow, the driver that ran a red light may have total responsibility.

  • Scenario C: A cyclist rides against the flow of traffic and collides with a vehicle making a right turn. In such instances, the cyclist's actions could contribute to their own injuries, reducing the liability of the turning driver.

Liability Factors in Right Turn Accidents

Determining liability in right-turn accidents depends on the specific circumstances of each case. The turning driver holds a significant level of responsibility and has a duty of care to exercise caution and yield to pedestrians and oncoming traffic. Failing to do so can result in legal consequences.

On the other hand, the driver traveling straight must also adhere to traffic laws and exercise reasonable care. However, if the driver traveling straight is speeding, runs a red light, or engages in other reckless behaviors, they may share liability for the accident.

Additionally, it's worth noting that pedestrians and cyclists also have a responsibility to follow traffic rules and exercise caution. If they fail to do so and contribute to the accident, their own liability may be considered.

Contributory Factors and Mitigating Circumstances

Assigning fault in a right-turn accident isn't always black and white. Contributory factors and mitigating circumstances can influence the determination of liability. Factors like adverse weather conditions, poor visibility, or mechanical failures might affect fault assignment.

Mitigating circumstances can also impact liability. For example, if a driver is forced to make a sudden evasive maneuver due to the actions of another driver, their liability may be reduced or eliminated altogether.

To establish a strong case, gathering evidence such as photographs, witness statements, and surveillance footage is crucial. These elements can provide valuable support in determining fault and protecting your rights.

Legal Considerations and Consequences

Understanding the legal considerations and consequences of a right-turn accident is essential for protecting your interests. If you are found at fault, you may be held liable for the damages incurred by the other party, including medical expenses, property damage, and lost wages. Insurance claims may be filed against you, potentially leading to increased premiums or even policy cancellation.

Conversely, if you are the victim of a right-turn accident, seeking legal representation can help you pursue compensation for your injuries and losses. Working with an experienced personal injury lawyer will ensure that your rights are protected, and your case is presented effectively.

Preventative Measures and Best Practices

While accidents can happen, taking proactive steps to prevent right-turn accidents is crucial. Here are some practical tips to help you stay safe on the road:

  • Always signal your intentions when making a right turn.

  • Be mindful of pedestrians and cyclists, yielding to them when necessary.

  • Observe traffic signals and signs, ensuring the intersection is clear before proceeding.

  • Avoid distractions while driving, focusing solely on the road.

  • Follow the speed limit and maintain a safe distance from other vehicles.

  • Continually scan your surroundings, anticipating potential hazards.

By adopting these preventative measures and practicing defensive driving, you can reduce the risk of right-turn accidents and keep yourself and others safe.

New York Right Turn Accident Lawyers

Understanding who is at fault in a right-turn accident in New York is essential for protecting your rights and seeking compensation. By familiarizing yourself with the right-of-way rules, liability factors, and legal considerations, you can navigate the complexities of these accidents more effectively. Remember to exercise caution, follow traffic laws, and seek legal guidance if you're involved in a right-turn accident. Together, we can strive to make our streets safer for everyone.

If you or a loved one was in a car accident in New York, the personal injury lawyers at Curan & Ahlers can help you to seek compensation. Contact us today for a free case review.


bottom of page